Event Deck Debate: Lovable v. PPT
If you attended Tuesday’s AI Guild session, you may have noticed we used Lovable for the presentation deck.
And if you didn’t attend the session live, you can see the replay at #Transparent Marketing, Part 2: How to earn the trust of a skeptical consumer... and machine - Oct. 13th, 2026
That wasn’t a random choice. @Flint McGlaughlin and I engaged in a hearty, till-now-private debate about the presentation medium. Flint had the idea that we should make the debate public to you in the AI Guild, because it may give you ideas for a vital question we all have to address in 2026 – when and how to use AI.
First is Flint’s viewpoint, and then my own. And please use the comment section to add your thoughts as well about how and when you choose to use artificial intelligence.
IF ARISTOTLE HAD POWERPOINT…
Dan,
When we spoke this morning, I shared my perspective without explaining the underlying work behind it. Here's a short summary of my logic.
On balance, it's why I'm leaning into the new presentation methodologies. I had AI summarize my notes... but this is my thinking (and it has been heavily edited by me). It draws on Balfour, Spinoza and Aristotle.
Essence and delivery
With modern content delivery, essence is what must survive the transformation of an idea into an experience. That might be:
- a distinction the audience must grasp
- a truth they must recognize
- a judgment they must become capable of making
The wording can change considerably while preserving that essence, or remain almost identical while losing it.
The important shift is from asking "Did we deliver the content?" to asking "What became present in the recipient's understanding?"
What can survive, and what cannot
A lecture converted into short videos illustrates the difference.
- Every major statement might appear somewhere in the clips, yet the argument can disappear because its sequence, qualifications, and accumulating evidence have been removed.
- The information survives; the intellectual relationship among its parts does not.
- Conversely, a carefully chosen interactive example might omit most of the lecture's words while enabling someone to grasp its central insight.
Three places where essence must be considered
- In the source: What is the indispensable claim, relationship, or experience?
- In the delivery: What must the form enable the audience to notice, connect, question, or feel?
- In the reception: What understanding or capacity remains after the presentation ends?
The third is decisive, although it does not replace fidelity to the source. A memorable misunderstanding is still a failure.
Why modern delivery changes the problem
Modern delivery becomes philosophically interesting because the medium increasingly participates in constructing the encounter.
- An interface determines sequence.
- A recommendation system determines context.
- An AI conversation determines which explanation a particular person receives.
These are editorial functions, even when performed automatically. They influence what appears central, what seems credible, and what never enters consideration.
So essence cannot be preserved simply by approving a master document. It requires identifying what may vary and what must remain invariant.
- May adapt: vocabulary, examples, pacing, and depth.
- Must survive: the truth conditions of a claim, its necessary qualifications, and the relationships essential to its meaning.
Same idea, different forms
Consider delivering the idea that correlation does not establish causation:
- Short video: an example that makes the missing causal inference visible.
- Interactive simulation: a way to see two variables move together because of a third.
- AI dialogue: questions that expose and correct the learner's particular inference.
- Long essay: a sustained account of why the inference fails and what further evidence is needed.
Each can accomplish something the others cannot. Fidelity does not require identical expression; it requires preserving the relevant intellectual achievement.
The boundary
There is also a boundary. Some essence resides in the encounter itself.
- The essence of a poem cannot necessarily be transferred into its summary.
- The force of testimony may depend on hearing the witness's voice.
- An ethical argument may require sustained attention to a difficulty that an efficient summary resolves too quickly.
Friction, duration, and ambiguity can be necessary features of understanding.
The key principle
Adapt delivery to the recipient, but let the essence govern the adaptation.
That changes the measure of success.
- Attention establishes that someone stayed.
- Recall establishes that something remained.
- Neither establishes that the essential meaning arrived.
A stronger test asks whether the person can:
- recognize the idea in a new situation
- distinguish it from a plausible distortion
- act with the judgment it was intended to support
Taken as a whole, there are arguments that support your position. But ultimately I am prioritizing substance and then looking for the most elegant form.
I may be wrong. But at least I am intentional. :)
Flint
BEFORE YOUR AUDIENCE VALUES THE MESSAGE, THEY MUST WANT TO ENGAGE
Flint,
For what it’s worth, I don’t disagree with most of what you say here. But I think there’s a piece that’s maybe missing? I’ve heard you call it acceptance in the past . So to add to your test…
- want to engage with the message based on the form it’s presented in
- recognize the idea in a new situation
- distinguish it from a plausible distortion
- act with the judgment it was intended to support
So to build on what you said about an interface determines sequence, I think an interface also determines acceptance, maybe?
I think if the form of the message pre-judges them in a negative way based on their previous experiences, the rest may be moot. They won’t try to engage. I can’t go as far back as Aristotle, but here are two quotes aimed at what I’m talking about…
“The medium is the message.” – Marshal McLuhan
"People's ideas about the medium shape the ways that medium will deliver a message. No matter what is actually said, the medium becomes part of what is being communicated." – Ilana Gershon
As for the Lovable slides specifically…
What I've noticed in myself personally is when I first saw the Lovable look and feel it seemed modern and cutting edge. Now I see it everywhere, but it's usually from fly-by-night small-bit players, not the major established companies and respected resources. So to me personally that aesthetic has become a non-verbal, even sub-concious indicator of low-authority, just-started, sometimes fake companies. It's like BlogSpot back in the day. At first it was a convenient way to publish. But then it often became a visual indicator of low-quality, keyword-stuffed spam. The Lovable aesthetic also gives an indication that the person just ran an AI prompt directly, with little thinking or input. Why should I spend my time consuming the content if they didn't spend their time crafting it?
I know I'm not good visually with PowerPoint slides. But my theory is it does signal hand-crafted thought. Just like I could buy a flawless piece of furniture at Ikea made out of fiberboard. And if I bought an actual hand-hewn piece of furniture it would have flaws, it would not be identical…but that's what makes it real and worth my time and human and makes me value it more. It reminds me of the book covers used by a Philosopher-Business-King I know 🙂
I know there's a balance with AI. And I do use it extensively behind the scenes. But I'm worried we lose our value prop -- the heritage, the decades, the craftsmanship -- and we just end up looking like everyone else's AI undifferentiated sludge if we use Lovable for event slides instead of man-made PowerPoint slides. Even if the content itself is truly good, the visual signaling loses people.
Even if it isn't all AI written, it feels like it is.
You mention Baruch Spinoza, so I’ll try to quote him as well to make my point. Spinoza put the underlying association this way: “If the mind has once been affected by two emotions at the same time, it will, whenever it is afterwards affected by one of these two, be also affected by the other.” That’s what I’m trying to describe: the look arrives carrying the associations of everything else I’ve seen that looks like it. We may have earned credibility through decades of work, but the visual form can signal something very different – before the audience gives the work a chance.
It's just something I've noticed bubbling in me over the past few months, and how my view of Lovable had subconciously changed. It's kind of like the uncanny valley. Even when I can't put my finger on it, I feel like something seems off with it. It's one reason I like the new MECLABS ai UI. It doesn't look like every other tool.
Daniel